PunditScore
Pundits › Simeon Gutman
SG

Simeon Gutman

Compare →
Managing Director, Retail Analyst at Morgan Stanley
Financial & Wall StreetFinanceRetail

Simeon Gutman is a managing director and senior retail analyst at Morgan Stanley, specializing in the consumer cyclical sector. He provides insights on retail earnings, consumer behavior, and market trends, often discussing the impact of economic factors such as tariffs and consumer spending on the retail landscape.

Score over time

The PunditScore after each graded call, on the panel's score bands.
Well above cohortAbove cohortAt cohort averageBelow cohortWell below cohort405060708090100#1#11#21#31#41Panel average per prediction — 56.3RIGHT2014-06-24 — Sign in to read this call.2014-11-17 — Sign in to read this call.2014-12-05 — Sign in to read this call.2017-12-14 — Sign in to read this call.2018-10-11 — Sign in to read this call.2018-10-11 — Sign in to read this call.2018-11-06 — Sign in to read this call.2019-01-23 — Sign in to read this call.2019-08-30 — Sign in to read this call.2019-11-21 — Sign in to read this call.2019-12-05 — Sign in to read this call.2020-08-19 — Sign in to read this call.2020-12-04 — Sign in to read this call.2020-12-04 — Sign in to read this call.2022-07-01 — Sign in to read this call.2022-07-01 — Sign in to read this call.2023-01-18 — Sign in to read this call.9/11/2024 — The price target of $300 was fulfilled within 2 days with a profit of $52.98 (21.45%) receiving and performance score of 107.24.2025-01-13 — Sign in to read this call.2025-03 — Sign in to read this call.2026-03-05 — Sign in to read this call.05/12/2026 — Sign in to read this call.06/03/2026 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07 — Sign in to read this call.08/07/2026 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-27 — OKTA will reach a price of $200.2026-08-28 — BBY will reach a price of $90.PARTLY2019-01-23 — Sign in to read this call.2021-05-08 — Sign in to read this call.2025-02-25 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-16 — Sign in to read this call.WRONG2017-11-10 — Sign in to read this call.2017-12-14 — Sign in to read this call.2017-12-14 — Sign in to read this call.2019-01-23 — Sign in to read this call.2019-01-23 — Sign in to read this call.2019-01-23 — Sign in to read this call.2019-08-14 — Sign in to read this call.2022-11-17 — Sign in to read this call.2022-11-28 — Sign in to read this call.2022-11-28 — Sign in to read this call.2022-11-28 — Sign in to read this call.OPEN2025-10 — Sign in to read this call.2026-01-15 — Sign in to read this call.2026-01-15 — Sign in to read this call.2026-02-18 — Sign in to read this call.2026-02-25 — Sign in to read this call.2026-03 — Sign in to read this call.2026-03-13 — Sign in to read this call.2026-03-18 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-22 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-18 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-20 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-20 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-27 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-01 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-01 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-01 — Sign in to read this call.06/03/2026 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-30 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-31 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-13 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-21 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-21 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-26 — DKS will reach a price of $180.2026-08-27 — WSM will reach a price of $240.2026-08-28 — DLTR will reach a price of $145.2026-09 — The STRONG BUY rating for Walmart Inc was maintained with a price target of $125.00.2026-09 — The HOLD rating for Advance Auto Parts Inc was maintained with a price target of $52.00.2026-09 — The STRONG BUY rating for Home Depot Inc was maintained with a price target of $400.00.09/03/2026 — Sign in to read this call.09/03/2026 — Sign in to read this call.09/11/2026 — Sign in to read this call.2026-10 — The STRONG BUY rating for Dick's Sporting Goods Inc was maintained with a price target of $180.00.
Hover a point to read the call. Click to pin it.
AXIS

Still open · 32

THE FRONT EDGE

Not resolved, so they don’t move the score. 1 past due and not yet graded.

?
Sign in to read this call.
Overdue since Oct 31, 2026 (12 months assumed)Said October 2025RetailWholesale
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Dec 1, 2026Said June 1, 2026Pet FoodConsumer Spending
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Feb 18, 2027Said February 18, 2026Stock PriceLESL
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Feb 25, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said February 25, 2026Stock PriceHD
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Mar 13, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said March 13, 2026Stock PriceDG
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Mar 18, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said March 18, 2026Stock PriceBOBS
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Mar 31, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said March 2026RetailHome Improvement
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Apr 22, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said April 22, 2026Stock PriceTSCO
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due May 18, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said May 18, 2026Stock PriceYSWY
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due May 20, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said May 20, 2026Stock PriceDRVN
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due May 20, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said May 20, 2026Stock PriceHD
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due May 27, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said May 27, 2026Stock PriceAZO
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Jun 3, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said June 3, 2026Stock PriceULTA
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Jul 30, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said July 30, 2026Stock PriceORLY
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Jul 31, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said July 31, 2026Stock PriceFND
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Aug 13, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 13, 2026Stock PriceEYE
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Aug 21, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 21, 2026Stock PriceAAP
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Aug 21, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 21, 2026Stock PriceWMT
No market prices this claim
?
DKS will reach a price of $180.
Due Aug 26, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 26, 2026Stock PriceDKS
No market prices this claim
?
WSM will reach a price of $240.
Due Aug 27, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 27, 2026Stock PriceWSM
No market prices this claim
?
DLTR will reach a price of $145.
Due Aug 28, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said August 28, 2026Stock PriceDLTR
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Sep 3, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 3, 2026Stock PriceOLLIE
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Sep 3, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 3, 2026Stock PriceFIVE
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Sep 11, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 11, 2026Stock PriceRH
No market prices this claim
?
The STRONG BUY rating for Walmart Inc was maintained with a price target of $125.00.
Due Sep 30, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 2026RetailGrocery
No market prices this claim
?
The HOLD rating for Advance Auto Parts Inc was maintained with a price target of $52.00.
Due Sep 30, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 2026AutomotiveRetail
No market prices this claim
?
The STRONG BUY rating for Home Depot Inc was maintained with a price target of $400.00.
Due Sep 30, 2027 (12 months assumed)Said September 2026RetailHome Improvement
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Dec 31, 2030Said June 1, 2026Pet SpendingMarket Growth
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Dec 31, 2030Said June 1, 2026Pet ServicesMarket Trends
No market prices this claim
?
The STRONG BUY rating for Dick's Sporting Goods Inc was maintained with a price target of $180.00.
Said October 2026RetailSports
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Said January 15, 2026Consumer Cyclical
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Said January 15, 2026Consumer Cyclical
No market prices this claim