PunditScore
Pundits › Scott Mendelson
SM

Scott Mendelson

Compare →
Box Office Analyst, Puck News · Film Critic, The Outside Scoop
Macro & structuralFilm & Entertainment

Scott Mendelson is a seasoned film critic and box office analyst known for his in-depth analysis of the theatrical business. He currently writes for Puck News and runs The Outside Scoop on Substack, where he provides insights into box office trends and audience sentiment.

Score over time

The PunditScore after each graded call, on the panel's score bands.
Well above cohortAbove cohortAt cohort averageBelow cohort5060708090100#1#11#21#31#41#51#61Panel average per prediction — 56.3RIGHT2011-05-06 — Sign in to read this call.2011-10-11 — Sign in to read this call.2011-10-11 — Sign in to read this call.2015-09-17 — Sign in to read this call.2015-09-17 — Sign in to read this call.2016-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2016-03-22 — Sign in to read this call.2016-07-14 — Sign in to read this call.2017-11-14 — Sign in to read this call.2020-06-16 — Sign in to read this call.2024-02-29 — Sign in to read this call.2024-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-03-22 — Sign in to read this call.2024-04-25 — Sign in to read this call.2024-06-15 — Sign in to read this call.2025-01-03 — Sign in to read this call.2025-12-20 — Sign in to read this call.2026-01-18 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-26 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-30 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-02 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-02 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05-22 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-12 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-15 — The estimated $20 million weekend for The End of Oak Street will be less of a win for WB than the estimated $18.5 million opening weekend for PAW Patrol: The Dino Movie will be for Paramount.2026-09-22 — Theaters are about to clinch a biggest-ever Q3 total.PARTLY2017-11-30 — Sign in to read this call.2018-04-06 — Sign in to read this call.2018-04-23 — Sign in to read this call.2024-02-29 — Sign in to read this call.2024-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-05-11 — Sign in to read this call.2026-01 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-30 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04-30 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-12 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-12 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-12 — Sign in to read this call.2026-06-12 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-03 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-17 — Sign in to read this call.WRONG2016-02-09 — Sign in to read this call.2017-03-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-01-03 — Sign in to read this call.2024-04-25 — Sign in to read this call.2024-04-25 — Sign in to read this call.2026-02 — Sign in to read this call.2026-02-28 — Sign in to read this call.2026-03 — Sign in to read this call.2026-04 — Sign in to read this call.2026-05 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-31 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-31 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08 — Sign in to read this call.2026-08-01 — Sign in to read this call.2026-09 — The top movie for September 2026 will be 'Dune: Part Two'.2026-09-27 — we can safely say that Avatar is about to get knocked down to second place for the second timeOPEN2026-01-07 — Sign in to read this call.2026-01-18 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-28 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-28 — Sign in to read this call.2026-07-28 — Sign in to read this call.2026-09-22 — Skydance will end 2026 owning two distribution studios.2026-09-27 — the Encore edition will finish with $34.5 million2026-09-27 — the best-case scenario is that it legs out like The Lion King 3-D ($94 million/$30 million in September 2011)2026-10 — The top movie for October 2026 will be 'Halloween Ends'.2026-11 — The top movie for November 2026 will be 'Fantastic Beasts 4'.2026-12 — The top movie for December 2026 will be 'Star Wars: Rogue Squadron'.
Hover a point to read the call. Click to pin it.
AXIS

Still open · 11

THE FRONT EDGE

Not resolved, so they don’t move the score. 1 past due and not yet graded.

?
The top movie for October 2026 will be 'Halloween Ends'.
Overdue since Oct 31, 2026Said October 2026Box OfficeMovies
No market prices this claim
?
The top movie for November 2026 will be 'Fantastic Beasts 4'.
Due Nov 30, 2026Said November 2026Box OfficeMovies
No market prices this claim
?
The top movie for December 2026 will be 'Star Wars: Rogue Squadron'.
Due Dec 31, 2026Said December 2026Box OfficeMovies
No market prices this claim
?
Skydance will end 2026 owning two distribution studios.
Due Dec 31, 2026Said September 22, 2026filmstudio ownership
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Dec 31, 2026Said July 28, 2026box officefilm
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Due Dec 31, 2026Said January 7, 2026box officepredictions
No market prices this claim
?
the Encore edition will finish with $34.5 million
Said September 27, 2026box officefilm
No market prices this claim
?
the best-case scenario is that it legs out like The Lion King 3-D ($94 million/$30 million in September 2011)
Said September 27, 2026box officefilm
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Said July 28, 2026box officefilm
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Said July 28, 2026box officefilm
No market prices this claim
?
Sign in to read this call.
Said January 18, 2026Box OfficeFilm
No market prices this claim