CJ
Caryn James is a prominent film and television critic for BBC Culture and a contributor to various publications including The Hollywood Reporter and The Wall Street Journal. With a background as the chief television critic for The New York Times, she has extensive experience in critiquing media and has authored two novels. James also serves as an adjunct professor in film studies at Columbia University.
No chart yet. A chart needs 8 resolved predictions, and Caryn has 6. The predictions themselves are below.
SORT
✓
Anderson has won every precursor award, including the Bafta and Directors Guild Award. He is also a likely winner as producer if One Battle wins best picture, and is a strong contender in adapted screenplay, so he could triple his Oscar haul in a single night. Whatever happens in those other categories, I don't see anyone else winning best director.
March 12, 2026OscarsCorrect
—
SCORE
✓
Picked Michael B. Jordan to win Best Actor at the 2026 Oscars.
March 12, 2026OscarsCorrect
—
SCORE
◇
The film is certain to win a best picture nomination, Anderson could win for adapted screenplay, Leo could get another best actor nod, and Sean Penn, Benicio del Toro and Teyana Taylor are strong in the supporting categories.
November 14, 2025OscarsToo vague to check
—
SCORE
✓
Anora – funny, original and a little bit heartbreaking – is the likely winner.
March 1, 2025OscarsCorrect
—
SCORE
✓
He has never won, but this is his year, and not only because he should win.
March 9, 2024call #5OscarsCorrect
88
SCORE
✓
Cillian Murphy is likely to win this award, as he should.
March 9, 2024call #6OscarsCorrect
93
SCORE
✓
Will Smith has picked up every major award in this category leading up to the Oscars, and is likely to win.
March 25, 2022call #1OscarsCorrect
93
SCORE
✓
Jessica Chastain might as well have had "Oscar bait" written across her forehead in fuchsia lipstick in the mediocre Eyes of Tammy Faye, but the strategy of acting-with-makeup worked well enough to get her a Screen Actors Guild award and most likely the Oscar.
March 25, 2022call #2OscarsCorrect
88
SCORE
✓
It will be a shock if Troy Kotsur doesn't follow his SAG and Bafta wins with an Oscar for his funny, touching performance as the father in Coda.
March 25, 2022call #3OscarsCorrect
88
SCORE
✓
No suspense here. Ariana DeBose has won every lead-up award so far for her kinetic singing/dancing/acting role in West Side Story.
March 25, 2022call #4OscarsCorrect
85
SCORE