CW
Carl Wilson is a Canadian music critic based in Toronto, currently serving as the music critic for Slate. He is the author of 'Let's Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste' and has contributed to various publications including Billboard and The New York Times.
No chart yet. A chart needs 8 resolved predictions, and Carl has 5. The predictions themselves are below.
SORT
✓
But Adele always seems like she sprang straight out of Grammy voters’ fantasies. I picture them intending to vote for Ms. Knowles but finding themselves unable to say no to the woman who pairs “old-fashioned songcraft,” as the cliché goes, with moving record-breaking mountains of actual physical albums.
pick list
February 2, 2017call #2GrammysCorrect
82
SCORE
✓
For Record of the Year, likewise, Grammy seems apt to say hiya back to Adele’s “Hello” rather than endorse the radicalism of Bey’s “Formation.”
February 2, 2017call #3GrammysCorrect
88
SCORE
✗
I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the Grammys chose to cap Bieber’s long-running redemption drama with that award, though a few might flinch at the way the “love” in “Love Yourself” seems like a euphemism for a more hostile four-letter word.
pick list
February 2, 2017call #4GrammysWrong
37
SCORE
✓
The millennial hustle is especially hot in Best New Artist, natch, and it looks to me like Chance the Rapper’s spot.
February 2, 2017call #5GrammysCorrect
85
SCORE
✗
My predictions are very near yours, though along with a Shakes upset I could also imagine a surprise Lamar sweep.
February 4, 2016call #1GrammysWrong
52
SCORE